Which Mini Muffin Pan Should You Buy in 2026? 8 With 24 Cups

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. When you click a product link on Restaurant Week Hawaii and buy something on Amazon, Amazon pays us a small commission; the price you pay is the same. Learn more.

A mini muffin tray comes out of the oven and half the batch stays glued to the cups.

Cup depth, coating and material decide that outcome more than the recipe does. With 24 small cups, one sticky pan means 24 small repairs. We compared eight 24-cup pans on listed specs to find the best mini muffin pan for different baking habits.

The choice comes down to a few numbers: cup size, oven limit, weight and care rules. Steel pans brown; silicone pans flex and store flat. Each pick below is set against the next one on a figure from its listing.

What we cover

The USA Pan 24-well pan is the top pick because its listing gives a lifetime warranty and a stated cup size of 1.88 x 1.25 inches. Choose the Aybloom if you want the highest listed oven limit at 500 °F, or the Fimary if you want a freezer-to-oven silicone pan.

What we did, and what we didn't

No pan was handled. The ranking comes from reading each maker’s listing and setting values side by side: material, oven limit, weight, cup size, care rules and warranty.

Listings cannot show how a coating wears, how a pan feels full, or how evenly it bakes. Where a field is missing or garbled, we say so and rank on what is stated.

8 listings were compared on item weight, item diameter, dimensions and capacity. No product was bought or physically handled: every figure is the manufacturer's listing value. Produced by Kitchen & Cookware Desk. Editorial responsibility: restaurantweekhawaii.com.

Which one fits you

• Warranty listed as Lifetime; cups 1.88 x 1.25 x 0.88 in USA Pan 24-well mini muffin pan
• Hottest oven recipes Upper temperature rating 500 °F, highest in the set Aybloom nonstick 24-cup pan
• Pan that goes freezer to oven Silicone with metal frame, rated to 450 °F, freezer safe Fimary silicone pan, metal frame
• Lightest, thinnest storage footprint 191 g and 0.7 in tall, lightest in the set CAKETIME single silicone mini pan
• Metal pan plus liners included Bundled with 200 mini liners; carbon steel Bake Choice pan with 200 liners
• Two pans for batch baking 2-pack, silicone with stainless frame, rated to 446 °F CAKETIME 2-pack reinforced silicone

The best Mini Muffin Pan: reviewed

1. USA Pan 24-well mini muffin pan

This is the only pick whose listing gives both a cup measurement and a warranty term. Cup size matters for mini muffins because bake time follows volume, and most rivals list only a top diameter or nothing at all.

The body is aluminized steel with a fluted surface, which the maker says adds strength against warping. The coating is described as free of PTFE, PFOA and BPA. Oven limit is 450 °F, level with Wilton and Fimary but 50 °F below the Aybloom.

Trade-off: the pan is 15.75 inches wide, the widest in the set, so check your oven rack. The listing also gives no cup diameter field and its capacity entry reads 8 inches, which is not a volume.

Full listing specifications

Included Components	24 Cup Mini Muffin Pan	Number of Packs	1
Manufacturer Warranty Description	Lifetime	Item Type Name	Mini Cupcake and Muffin Pan
Upper Temperature Rating	450 °F	Item Dimensions D x W x H	11.25"D x 15.75"W x 0.85"H
Capacity	8 inches	Item Weight	454 g
number_of_cups	24	Size	24 Cup

2. Aybloom nonstick 24-cup pan

Carbon steel, 24 cups, and a 500 °F rating make this the pick for recipes that run hot. It is also the only metal pan here labelled dishwasher safe, though Bake Choice advises against that for its own coating.

Weight is 9.6 ounces, lighter than Wilton at 16 ounces, which suggests thinner metal; the listing does not say gauge.

Gaps: the listing has no feature bullets and states no cup diameter. Its dimension line reads 0.9 inches wide and 10.12 inches tall, which looks like a mix-up of fields, so rely on the cup count only.

Full listing specifications

Included Components	24 Cups Mini Muffin Pan	Number of Packs	1
Item Type Name	Cupcake Pan	Upper Temperature Rating	500 °F
Item Dimensions D x W x H	14.8"D x 0.9"W x 10.12"H	Capacity	24 cups
Item Weight	9.6 ounces	number_of_cups	24
Size	24 Cups	Color	Black

3. Wilton Gold non-stick 24-cup pan

Wilton lists the smallest cup diameter in the set at 1.5 inches, so these are true bite-size. Pan footprint is 16 by 10 inches, 1 inch deep, with extended handles for lifting.

It weighs 16 ounces, among the heavier metal pans, and the listing ties that to even heat and warp resistance. The coating is stated as made without PFAS, which the USA Pan listing words differently as PTFE and PFOA free.

Limit: 450 °F, and the listing gives no care instruction on dishwashers. Wilton also sells a 6-pack of the same pan.

Full listing specifications

Included Components	pan	Number of Packs	1
Manufacturer Warranty Description	Warranty	Item Type Name	24-Cup Mini Muffin Tin, Steel
Upper Temperature Rating	450 °F	Item Dimensions D x W x H	10"D x 16"W x 1"H
Capacity	24 cups	Item Weight	16 ounces
Item Diameter	1.5 inches	number_of_cups	24

4. Bake Choice carbon steel mini pan

The pan is 15.4 inches deep and 10.3 wide, at 0.8 inch tall. Care advice is hand-washing to protect the coating, a stricter rule than Aybloom’s dishwasher label.

The diameter field reads 10.3 inches, which is the pan width and not a cup size, and capacity is given as 1.2 pounds. Neither helps a buyer sizing cups.

The listing’s own text says 24 bite-sized treats, so cups are small, but the pan gives you nothing to measure a liner or recipe against.

Full listing specifications

Included Components	1 Pack Mini Muffin Pan	Number of Packs	1
Special Feature	Easy Release, Even Heat Distribution, Nonstick	Item Dimensions D x W x H	15.4"D x 10.3"W x 0.8"H
Capacity	1.2 pounds	Item Weight	15.2 ounces
Item Diameter	10.3 inches	number_of_cups	24
Size	Mini	Color	Dark Gray

5. Bake Choice pan with 200 liners

The bundle pairs a carbon steel pan with 200 liners, which covers more than eight batches of 24. That is the deciding fact, since the pan itself matches the plain Bake Choice.

Spec fields conflict: the title copy says 0.86 inch tall while the dimension line says 1.57, and the diameter field reads 14.96 inches. Temperature is given as 232 °C, about the same ceiling as the 450 °F pans.

It is the heaviest metal pan at 0.54 kg, and care advice is hand-washing.

Full listing specifications

Included Components	1pcs Mini Muffin Pan & 200pcs Mini Cupcake Liners	Number of Packs	1
Item Type Name	Mini Muffin Pan	Upper Temperature Rating	232 °C
Item Dimensions D x W x H	14.96"D x 10.6"W x 1.57"H	Capacity	24 cups
Item Weight	0.54 kg	Item Diameter	14.96 inches
number_of_cups	24	Size	Mini 24 cup

6. Fimary silicone pan, metal frame

The frame keeps the silicone from sagging when you carry batter, which plain silicone pans lack. The listing gives 1.8 inch cups, 0.7 inch deep, in a 15.3 by 9.2 inch pan.

Silicone releases by flexing, so you press cups out and skip grease, per the listing. It also stores flat, at 0.71 inch tall.

Trade-off: silicone does not brown like steel, and the listing makes no claim that it does. Capacity is given as 19.87 g, not a volume.

Full listing specifications

Included Components	silicone muffin pan	Number of Packs	1
Manufacture Year	2026	Item Type Name	24-Cups Muffin Pans With Metal Reinforced Frame
Special Feature	Freezer Safe, Nonstick, Odor Free, Oven Safe	Item Dimensions D x W x H	15.3"D x 9.2"W x 0.71"H
Capacity	19.87 g	Item Weight	0.34 kg
Item Diameter	1.8 inches	number_of_cups	24

7. CAKETIME 2-pack reinforced silicone

Two pans give 48 cups per oven run. Cups are 1.8 inches across and 0.9 inch deep, deeper than the 0.7 inch of Fimary and the CAKETIME single.

Limit is 446 °F, a few degrees under the 450 °F pans. The frame has rigid handles, and the listing adds rust resistant and microwave safe.

The listed 500 g weight is likely for the set. Two oven racks are needed to use both pans at once.

Full listing specifications

Included Components	no	Number of Packs	2
Special Feature	Freezer Safe, Microwave Safe, Nonstick, Oven Safe, Rust Resistant	Item Dimensions D x W x H	15.3"D x 9.2"W x 0.9"H
Capacity	0.6 fluid ounces	Item Weight	500 g
Item Diameter	1.8 inches	number_of_cups	24
Size	24-Cup Mini	Color	Creamy Confetti

8. CAKETIME single silicone mini pan

This is the lightest and slimmest of the eight, at 191 g and 0.7 inch tall, in a 9.4 by 13 inch pan. It has no frame, and the listing tells you to set it on a metal tray before filling.

Range is -104 to 446 °F, with oven, microwave, dishwasher and freezer use all listed. Cups are 1.8 inches, 0.7 deep.

That extra sheet is the cost: a loaded floppy pan is hard to carry on its own.

Full listing specifications

Included Components	Cake Dish, Cake Pan, Mold	Number of Packs	1
Special Feature	Heat Resistant	Item Dimensions D x W x H	9.4"D x 13"W x 0.7"H
Capacity	17.01 g	Item Weight	191 g
Item Diameter	1.8 inches	number_of_cups	24
Size	24-Cup Mini	Color	Red

What to know before buying Mini Muffin Pan

Checklist

• Cup count: all eight list 24 cups, so other specs decide.
• Material: steel browns; silicone flexes and stores flat.
• Oven limit: listed from 446 to 500 °F; check against your recipes.
• Cup size: only some listings state it; 1.5 to 1.88 inches where given.
• Care rules: dishwasher safe on some, hand-wash only on Bake Choice.
• Footprint: widths run 9.2 to 16 inches; measure your oven.

Questions about mini muffin pans

Is steel or silicone better for mini muffins?

Steel gives browning and rigidity; silicone gives easy release and flat storage. Frameless silicone needs a baking sheet.

What oven limit is enough?

450 °F covers most muffin recipes. Only Aybloom lists 500 °F.

Do I need liners?

Nonstick pans may not need them, but Bake Choice bundles 200 if you like them.

Why does the cup size matter?

Smaller cups bake faster. Wilton lists 1.5 inch cups, USA Pan 1.88 by 1.25 inches.

Can I put them in the dishwasher?

Aybloom and the CAKETIME silicone pans list it; Bake Choice advises hand-washing.

The verdict

The USA Pan suits bakers who want a metal pan with a stated cup size and a lifetime warranty. The Aybloom wins if your recipes run hotter, at its 500 °F limit.

Skip the category if you bake only a few mini muffins a year; a standard pan with shorter bake time does the job.