Restaurant WeekHawaii

Top 7 Carbon Steel Pans of 2026: 10 to 13.5 Inch Sizes

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. When you click a product link on Restaurant Week Hawaii and buy something on Amazon, Amazon pays us a small commission; the price you pay is the same. Learn more.

Merten & Storck's 12-inch skillet takes first place for its 600°F oven rating, with Lodge ahead if a lifetime warranty matters more.

The best carbon steel pan depends on which spec you weigh. Oven temperature runs from 400°F to 600°F across these seven.

The Merten & Storck 12-inch combines the top temperature rating with a riveted steel handle. Lodge wins on warranty, Yonida on cool handles, and YOSUKATA if you stir-fry.

Our top picks for Carbon Steel Pan

Merten & Storck's 12-inch skillet leads on a 600°F oven rating and a riveted steel handle. Lodge wins for a 10-inch pan with a lifetime warranty, Yonida's silicone-gripped pans suit stovetop-only handling, and YOSUKATA is the pick if you stir-fry.

Why these picks

None of these pans were handled. The ranking comes from setting the manufacturers’ listed specifications against each other: maximum temperature, capacity, weight, handle material, care rules and warranty.

Listings cannot show how a handle feels, how evenly a pan heats, or how a seasoning holds up. Where a figure is missing, such as weight on both Yonida pans, it is flagged instead of guessed.

7 listings were compared on capacity, maximum temperature, item weight and handle material. No product was bought or physically handled: every figure is the manufacturer's listing value. Produced by Kitchen & Cookware Desk. Editorial responsibility: restaurantweekhawaii.com.

The spec sheet

Each table lists the same fields per pick, so you can compare down a column: maximum temperature, capacity, weight, handle material and care.

Blank or unstated values mean the listing gives no figure.

1Merten & Storck Pre-Seasoned Carbon Steel 12" Frying Pan Skillet, Cast Iron Lightweight, Durable, Sear Grill Broil Fry, Indoor Outdoor Cooking, Easy to Clean, Oven Safe, Induction, Steel Handle, Black
Best Overall
Cooks wanting a large oven-to-stovetop skillet
2Lodge Pre-Seasoned Carbon Steel Skillet, Long Handle, 10 Inches
Best Warranty
Buyers wanting a warranty-backed 10-inch skillet
3Carbon Steel Pan, 12 Inch Nonstick Frying Pan Skillet
Largest Capacity
Stovetop cooks wanting a big pan with a cool grip
4Carbon Steel Pan, 10 Inch Nonstick Frying Pan Skillet
Best Compact Cool-Grip
Smaller households wanting a cool grip
5Merten & Storck 10" Pre-Seasoned Carbon Steel Frying Pan Skillet
Lightest Skillet
Lighter handling for one or two servings
7de Buyer MINERAL B Carbon Steel Fry Pan - 9.5” Diameter, 6.9” Cooking Surface - Ideal for Searing, Sauteing & Reheating - Naturally Non-Stick Finish - Made in France
Best for Small Portions
Eggs and reheating in a small pan

Pick by situation

The picks, reviewed

1. Merten & Storck 12-inch carbon steel skillet

Merten & Storck Pre-Seasoned Carbon Steel 12" Frying Pan Skillet, Cast Iron Lightweight, Durable, Sear Grill Broil Fry, Indoor Outdoor Cooking, Easy to Clean, Oven Safe, Induction, Steel Handle, Black1 · Best Overall

Verdict: For cooks who want one large skillet that handles oven, grill and induction; the 600°F rating and riveted steel handle decide it.

  • 4 cups Capacity
  • 600 °F Maximum Temperature
  • 1.5 kg Item Weight
  • Alloy Steel Handle Material

Best for Cooks wanting a large oven-to-stovetop skillet

Skip it if You want a cool-touch handle on the stovetop; look at the Yonida pans.

What we like
  • 600°F oven rating, 100°F above Lodge
  • Triple-riveted steel handle
  • Listed 4-cup capacity at 12 inches
What could be better
  • Hand wash only
  • Higher-priced in this set
  • No removable cool-grip handle holder like Yonida's

Against the next pick: It beats the Lodge on oven limit (600°F against 500°F) but loses on warranty, since Lodge lists a lifetime one and this listing states none.

Also sold as: 10" Frying Pan Skillet / Black, 8" Frying Pan Skillet (Pack of 6) / Black, 8" Frying Pan Skillet / Black.

The deciding figure is 600°F. Only the Lodge (500°F) and de Buyer (400°F) rate lower, so this pan is the safer choice for hot-oven finishing and grill use. The listing also names induction, gas and electric coil compatibility.

The listing calls it lighter than cast iron but gives no cast iron figure to compare against.

The trade-off is care. It is hand wash only, and the listing says nonstick performance builds with use rather than arriving on day one. It is also in the higher-priced band here, while Lodge and Yonida sit lower.

Full listing specifications
Recommended Uses For Product: Indoor cooking, outdoor cooking, searing, grilling, campingNumber of Packs: 1Included Components: 12" Frying Pan SkilletItem Type Name: Pre-Seasoned Carbon Steel Frying Pan SkilletMaterial Type: Carbon SteelProduct Care Instructions: Hand Wash OnlyHandle Material: Alloy SteelMetal Type: Carbon SteelCoating Description: SteelAdditional Features: Gas Stovetop Compatible, Induction Stovetop Compatible, Lightweight, Oven Safe, Scratch Resistant

2. Lodge seasoned carbon steel skillet

Lodge Pre-Seasoned Carbon Steel Skillet, Long Handle, 10 Inches2 · Best Warranty

Verdict: A 10-inch, all-carbon-steel skillet with a lifetime limited warranty, for buyers who value a stated guarantee over the highest heat rating.

  • 2 quarts Capacity
  • 500 °F Maximum Temperature
  • 3.1 pounds Item Weight
  • Carbon Steel Handle Material

Best for Buyers wanting a warranty-backed 10-inch skillet

Skip it if You regularly cook above 500°F; choose the Merten & Storck 12-inch.

What we like
  • Lifetime limited warranty listed
  • Carbon steel handle, no parts to remove
  • Lower-priced in this set
What could be better
  • 500°F maximum is lower than most picks
  • No capacity stated
  • Hand wash only

Against the next pick: It beats the 12-inch Yonida on warranty and an all-steel handle, but loses on rated heat, 500°F against 600°F.

Also sold as: 8 Inch, 10 Inch (Pack of 3), 12 Inch.

Lodge is the only skillet here that pairs a stated lifetime limited warranty with a made-in-USA claim. The handle is carbon steel too, so the whole pan goes in a hot oven without removing parts.

Limit: 500°F maximum, 100°F under the Merten & Storck.

Hand wash only. The listing also gives no capacity figure, so volume against the others cannot be compared.

Full listing specifications
Recommended Uses For Product: Use in the oven, on the stove, on the grill, or over a campfireItem Highlight: Lightweight High Heat Frying Pan with Long Handle for Quick Temperature Response, Ideal for Searing & SautéingManufacturer Warranty Description: Lifetime limited manufacturer's warrantyIncluded Components: skilletItem Type Name: SkilletMaterial Type: Carbon SteelProduct Care Instructions: Hand Wash Only, Oven SafeHandle Material: Carbon SteelMetal Type: Carbon SteelCoating Description: Carbon Steel

3. Yonida 12-inch carbon steel pan

Carbon Steel Pan, 12 Inch Nonstick Frying Pan Skillet3 · Largest Capacity

Verdict: The biggest listed capacity here at 67.63 fl oz, with a removable silicone handle holder for cool grip on the stove.

  • 2 liters Capacity
  • 600 °F Maximum Temperature
  • not stated Item Weight
  • Silicone Handle Material

Best for Stovetop cooks wanting a big pan with a cool grip

Skip it if You want a fixed steel handle you can leave on in the oven.

What we like
  • 67.63 fl oz, highest capacity listed
  • Removable silicone handle holder
  • 600°F maximum
What could be better
  • Weight not stated
  • Holder must come off for the oven
  • Care instructions are mixed

Against the next pick: It beats the 10-inch Yonida on capacity (67.63 against 64 fl oz) but states no more about weight than that pan does.

Also sold as: Black / 12in w/lid, Black / 10in.

Capacity is listed at 2 liters, the highest figure among these pans. The silicone holder keeps the handle cool on the stovetop and comes off for the oven.

Gaps matter. The listing does not state weight. It lists both dishwasher safe and a hand-wash, dry and oil routine in its features; those conflict, so follow the oil routine.

Max temperature is 600°F, matching the top group, though the holder must come off first.

Full listing specifications
Recommended Uses For Product: Sautéing, searing, frying, griddling, baking, roasting, broilingNumber of Packs: 1Item Highlight: Pre-Seasoned Carbon Steel Cookware with Removable Silicone Handle Holder, Indoor/Outdoor, Oven SafeIncluded Components: Silicone Handle HolderMaterial Type: Carbon SteelProduct Care Instructions: Dishwasher Safe, Oven SafeHandle Material: SiliconeMetal Type: Carbon SteelCoating Description: non-stickAdditional Features: Electric Stovetop Compatible, Gas Stovetop Compatible, Induction Stovetop Compatible, Non Stick

4. Yonida 10-inch carbon steel pan

Carbon Steel Pan, 10 Inch Nonstick Frying Pan Skillet4 · Best Compact Cool-Grip

Verdict: A 10-inch pan with the same removable silicone holder and 600°F rating, for smaller households.

  • 2 quarts Capacity
  • 600 °F Maximum Temperature
  • not stated Item Weight
  • Silicone Handle Material

Best for Smaller households wanting a cool grip

Skip it if You want a stated warranty; the Lodge lists one.

What we like
  • 600°F maximum, 100°F above Lodge
  • Removable silicone holder
  • Lower-priced in this set
What could be better
  • Weight not stated
  • Included components unclear
  • Holder off before oven use

Against the next pick: It does not state weight.

Also sold as: Black / 12in w/lid, Black / 12in.

This is the smaller sibling: 64 fl oz against 67.63, same holder, same 600°F rating. Handle material is silicone, so the grip stays cool but must be removed for oven use.

Weight is not stated, which limits comparison with the Lodge at 3.1 lb. The included-components field reads only “no”, so what ships in the box is unclear.

Other sizes exist, including a 12-inch and lidded versions.

Full listing specifications
Recommended Uses For Product: Sautéing, searing, frying, griddling, baking, roasting, broilingNumber of Packs: 1Item Highlight: Pre-Seasoned Carbon Steel Cookware with Removable Silicone Handle Holder, Indoor/Outdoor, Oven SafeIncluded Components: noMaterial Type: Carbon SteelProduct Care Instructions: Dishwasher Safe, Oven SafeHandle Material: SiliconeMetal Type: Carbon SteelCoating Description: non-stickAdditional Features: Electric Stovetop Compatible, Gas Stovetop Compatible, Induction Stovetop Compatible, Non Stick

5. Merten & Storck 10-inch carbon steel skillet

Merten & Storck 10" Pre-Seasoned Carbon Steel Frying Pan Skillet5 · Lightest Skillet

Verdict: It has a 600°F rating and is described as lightweight.

  • 3 cups Capacity
  • 600 °F Maximum Temperature
  • 1.2 kg Item Weight
  • Metal Handle Material

Best for Lighter handling for one or two servings

Skip it if You cook for four; the 12-inch Merten & Storck holds more.

What we like
  • 2.65 lb, lightest in the set
  • 600°F maximum
  • Induction, gas and electric compatible
What could be better
  • 24 fl oz capacity is small
  • Hand wash only

Against the next pick: It beats the YOSUKATA wok on weight (2.65 against 3.53 lb) but holds far less, 24 against 56.32 fl oz.

Also sold as: 8" Frying Pan Skillet (Pack of 6) / Black, 12" Frying Pan Skillet / Black, 8" Frying Pan Skillet / Black.

It keeps the 600°F rating and riveted steel handle. It keeps the 600°F rating and riveted steel handle.

The listing does not state a capacity. It is hand wash only and mid-priced in this set.

Full listing specifications
Recommended Uses For Product: Frying, Grilling, Pan Roasting, SearingNumber of Packs: 1Item Highlight: Natural Nonstick with Use, Induction & All Stovetop Suitable, Grill & Campfire Safe, Even Heating, Indoor/Outdoor UseIncluded Components: 10" Frying Pan SkilletItem Type Name: Pre-Seasoned Carbon Steel Frying Pan SkilletMaterial Type: Carbon SteelProduct Care Instructions: Hand Wash Only, Oven SafeHandle Material: MetalMetal Type: Carbon SteelCoating Description: Steel

6. YOSUKATA 13.5-inch flat-bottom wok

YOSUKATA 13.5" Pre-Seasoned Flat Bottom Black Carbon Steel Wok for Stir Fry6 · Best for Stir-Fry

Verdict: A 13.5-inch flat-bottom wok at 56.32 fl oz, for stir-fry on electric or induction tops where a round wok rocks.

  • 0.44 gallons Capacity
  • 600 °F Maximum Temperature
  • 1.6 kg Item Weight
  • 600 °F Maximum TemperatureNew Zealand Beech Wood Handle Material Handle Material

Best for Stir-fry on flat cooktops

Skip it if You want a skillet for searing; pick the Merten & Storck.

What we like
  • 13.5-inch flat bottom for induction
  • 56.32 fl oz capacity
  • 600°F maximum
What could be better
  • 3.53 lb, heaviest listed
  • 30-day warranty only
  • Wood handle limits flame use

Against the next pick: It beats the de Buyer on capacity (56.32 against 16.91 fl oz) but is heavier and carries a shorter warranty.

This is a wok, not a skillet, so it fits stir-fry, braising and deep-frying better than searing. Flat bottom suits induction and electric; the listing also names grills and open fire.

The beech handle is wood, so keep it off direct flame. The warranty is 30 days, against lifetime on Lodge and de Buyer.

Full listing specifications
Recommended Uses For Product: stir-frying, deep-frying, pan-frying, braising, grillingNumber of Packs: 1Item Highlight: Pow Wok for Stir Fry, BBQ, Grill, Camping – Traditional Chinese Cookware for Induction, Electric, Gas, Open FireManufacturer Warranty Description: 30 daysIncluded Components: wokItem Type Name: WokMaterial Type: Carbon SteelProduct Care Instructions: Hand Wash OnlyHandle Material: New Zealand Beech WoodMetal Type: Carbon Steel

7. de Buyer MINERAL B fry pan

de Buyer MINERAL B Carbon Steel Fry Pan - 9.5” Diameter, 6.9” Cooking Surface - Ideal for Searing, Sauteing & Reheating - Naturally Non-Stick Finish - Made in France7 · Best for Small Portions

Verdict: A 9.5-inch French-made pan with a 6.9-inch cooking surface and lifetime warranty, but only a 400°F oven limit.

  • 0.5 liters Capacity
  • 400 °F Maximum Temperature
  • 3 pounds Item Weight
  • 0.5 liters Capacity400 °F Maximum TemperatureCarbon Steel,Stainless Steel Handle Material Handle Material

Best for Eggs and reheating in a small pan

Skip it if You want a pre-seasoned pan; take the Lodge.

What we like
  • Lifetime warranty listed
  • Made in France
  • Carbon and stainless handle
What could be better
  • 400°F, 10-minute oven limit
  • 16.91 fl oz capacity is smallest
  • Needs seasoning before use

Against the next pick: It beats the YOSUKATA on warranty and weight (3.0 against 3.53 lb) but holds 16.91 fl oz against 56.32.

Also sold as: 14", 10.25", 8", 11".

The 400°F limit is the lowest here, and the listing restricts oven use to 10 minutes. Capacity is 16.91 fl oz, the smallest.

It ships with beeswax that must be washed off and seasoned before first use, unlike the pre-seasoned skillets.

Full listing specifications
Recommended Uses For Product: Searing, Sautéing, Cooking Eggs/OmeletsManufacturer Warranty Description: LifetimeIncluded Components: Fry PanItem Type Name: de Buyer Carbon Steel Fry PanMaterial Type: Carbon SteelProduct Care Instructions: Hand Wash OnlyHandle Material: Carbon Steel,Stainless SteelMetal Type: Carbon SteelCoating Description: Washable Protective Beeswax/Natural NonstickAdditional Features: Electric Stovetop Compatible, Gas Stovetop Compatible, Induction Stovetop Compatible

How to choose Carbon Steel Pan

  • Maximum temperature. Ratings run 400°F to 600°F; higher suits oven finishing and grills.
  • Handle material. Steel goes in the oven whole; silicone or wood needs care near heat.
  • Weight. Listed weights span 2.65 to 3.53 lb; lighter eases one-handed pouring.
  • Capacity. Listed from 16.91 to 67.63 fl oz; match to servings.
  • Pre-seasoning. Most arrive seasoned; de Buyer needs seasoning first.
  • Warranty. Lodge and de Buyer list lifetime; YOSUKATA lists 30 days.

Questions about carbon steel pans

How hot does the pan need to go?

For stovetop searing any listed rating is enough. For oven finishing, 500°F or more removes limits.

Does pre-seasoned mean nonstick?

Listings say nonstick builds with use, so expect it to improve rather than start slick.

Can I put it in the dishwasher?

Most listings say hand wash only. One Yonida listing says dishwasher safe but also advises oiling after hand washing.

Does it work on induction?

All seven list induction compatibility.

Which size fits one person?

The 10-inch pans, at 24 to 64 fl oz, or the de Buyer for small tasks.

Do other sizes exist?

Yes, Merten & Storck, Lodge, Yonida and de Buyer sell other sizes.

So which one?

Merten & Storck’s 12-inch skillet is for cooks who want one large pan that survives a 600°F oven. Lodge wins if a lifetime warranty counts more, and YOSUKATA if stir-fry is the job.

Skip carbon steel altogether if you want a dishwasher-safe pan with no seasoning upkeep.

What changed
  • Published guide
  • Guide drafted

Read the full method.