7 Best Pizza Steels in 2026: 16×16, 3/8″ Thick & Pre-Seasoned
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. When you click a product link on Restaurant Week Hawaii and buy something on Amazon, Amazon pays us a small commission; the price you pay is the same. Learn more.
Three numbers decide a pizza steel: how much of your oven it fills, how thick it is, and how much it weighs.
Start with footprint. Measure your oven rack depth and width, then compare to the plate. A 16 x 16 in steel takes a 15 in pie; 13 x 13 in does not.
Next, thickness. Most picks here are 0.25 in; one is 0.38 in. Thicker stores more heat for back-to-back baking but adds weight, from about 13 lb to 27 lb.
Then check the listed maximum temperature. It runs from 500 °F to 1112 °F, and three listings state none. The best pizza steel for you is the one whose size and heat rating match your oven and your baking rhythm.
In this guide
The ThermiChef 1/4" 16×16 steel leads because it pairs a full 16 x 16 in footprint with a listed 1000 °F ceiling at 17.6 lb. If you bake back-to-back pizzas and can lift 27 lb, the ThermiChef 3/8" wins. For a small oven, the Hans Grill 13 x 13 fits.
- Best for Batch Baking ThermiChef 3/8" Deluxe steel
- Best for Small Ovens Hans Grill Pizza Steel Pro 13x13
- Best Pre-Seasoned Value VEVOR 16x14.5 pre-seasoned steel
- Best with Lifting Hole Chef Pomodoro 16 in seasoned steel
- Best Gift Set Caldoro 16x16 steel with cutter
- Best Lower-Priced Rectangle Boachee XL 16x13.4 carbon steel
The research behind this guide
No product was handled. The ranking comes from comparing manufacturer listing specs: dimensions, thickness, weight, maximum temperature, seasoning status and what is included.
Listings cannot tell a buyer how a steel fits a given oven, how it feels to lift, or how the finish ages. Treat the picks as a spec comparison.
8 listings were compared on item weight, maximum temperature, dimensions and material type. 1 was set aside (1 beaten on a listed spec). No product was bought or physically handled: every figure is the manufacturer's listing value. Produced by Kitchen & Cookware Desk. Editorial responsibility: restaurantweekhawaii.com.
Which one fits you
- One pizza at a time, standard oven 16 x 16 in, 0.25 in thick, 17.6 lb ThermiChef 1/4" 16×16 steel
- Back-to-back pizzas for a crowd 0.38 in thick, 27 lb of steel ThermiChef 3/8" Deluxe steel
- Small or apartment oven 13 x 13 in, 13.1 lb, 1112 °F listed Hans Grill Pizza Steel Pro 13×13
- Skip seasoning before first bake Listed as pre-seasoned, 16 x 14.5 in VEVOR 16×14.5 pre-seasoned steel
- Gift set with a cutter Includes 14 in oak-handle rocker cutter Caldoro 16×16 steel with cutter
- Finger hole for lifting Corner hole, 932 °F listed maximum Chef Pomodoro 16 in seasoned steel
The picks in detail
1. ThermiChef 1/4" 16×16 steel
1 · Best Overall
Verdict: For a standard oven and one pizza at a time: 16 x 16 in at 0.25 in thick, with a listed 1000 °F limit.
- 17.6 pounds Item Weight
- 1000 °F Maximum Temperature
- 16"L x 16"W x 0.25"Th Dimensions
- 1/4" Steel Version Material Type
Best for Home cooks with a full-size oven baking one or two pizzas per session
Skip it if You want a steel that arrives seasoned, or your oven is too shallow for a 16 in plate.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| 16 x 16 in, the widest footprint in the set | Not pre-seasoned; needs a one-hour seasoning bake |
| Listed 1000 °F maximum | Heavier than the 13 to 15 lb rectangular steels |
| Other sizes sold, including 14 x 14 and 14 x 20 |
Against the next pick: Beats the ThermiChef 3/8 in on handling at roughly 10 lb lighter, but holds less heat for back-to-back baking.
Also sold as: 3/8" Deluxe Version / 14" x 14" Square, 3/8" Deluxe Version / 14" x 20" Rectangular, 1/4" Steel Version / 14" x 20" Rectangular, 1/4" Steel Version / 15.7" x 15.7" Square.
The deciding spec is the footprint. At 16 x 16 in this is the widest steel here by a small margin, and the listing says it takes pies up to 15 in. The cost is oven fit: the listing tells you to measure depth first and points to a 14 x 14 size for compact ovens.
Thickness is 0.25 in, which the listing calls the balance between heat retention and weight. It sits at 17.6 lb, well below the 3/8 in sibling and a few pounds above the 13 to 15 lb rectangular steels.
Preparation is the catch. It ships shot-blasted and not pre-seasoned, so a one-hour 375°F oil bake comes first. Hand wash only.
Full listing specifications
| Item Weight | 17.6 pounds | Size | 16" x 16" Square |
|---|---|---|---|
| Number of Packs | 1 | Included Components | Pizza Steel |
| Item Type Name | Pizza Steel | Maximum Temperature | 1000 °F |
| Item Dimensions L x W x Thickness | 16"L x 16"W x 0.25"Th | Item Highlight | Multipurpose Cooking Steel for Pizzas, Sourdough, Grilling & More - Made in the USA |
| Material Type | 1/4" Steel Version | Product Care Instructions | Hand Wash |
2. ThermiChef 3/8" Deluxe steel
2 · Best for Batch Baking
Verdict: For hosts baking pizzas in a row: 0.38 in thickness adds heat storage, at 27 lb.
- 27 pounds Item Weight
- 1000 °F Maximum Temperature
- 16"L x 16"W x 0.38"Th Dimensions
- 3/8" Deluxe Version Material Type
Best for Hosts and batch bakers who rotate several pizzas
Skip it if You bake one pizza at a time; the 1/4 in ThermiChef gives most of the result.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| 0.38 in thick, the thickest listed | 27 lb is the heaviest in the set |
| Same 16 x 16 in footprint as the top pick | Needs seasoning before first use |
| Listed 1000 °F maximum | Higher-priced than the 1/4 in version |
Against the next pick: Holds more steel than the Hans Grill by about 14 lb, which is a handling penalty the smaller plate avoids.
Also sold as: 3/8" Deluxe Version / 14" x 14" Square, 3/8" Deluxe Version / 14" x 20" Rectangular, 1/4" Steel Version / 16" x 16" Square, 1/4" Steel Version / 14" x 20" Rectangular.
This is the same 16 x 16 in plate as the top pick but 0.38 in thick against 0.25 in. The listing says the extra mass stores more heat and recovers faster between pizzas.
The price of that is weight: 27 lb, the heaviest here and nearly double most of the field. Moving it in and out of a hot oven is the real constraint.
Maximum temperature is listed at 1000 °F and it needs the same seasoning step. It also sits in the higher-priced group of this set.
Full listing specifications
| Item Weight | 27 pounds | Size | 16" x 16" Square |
|---|---|---|---|
| Number of Packs | 1 | Included Components | Pizza Steel |
| Item Type Name | Pizza Steel | Maximum Temperature | 1000 °F |
| Item Dimensions L x W x Thickness | 16"L x 16"W x 0.38"Th | Item Highlight | Multipurpose Cooking Steel for Pizzas, Sourdough, Grilling & More - Made in the USA |
| Material Type | 3/8" Deluxe Version | Product Care Instructions | Hand Wash |
3. Hans Grill Pizza Steel Pro 13×13
3 · Best for Small Ovens
Verdict: For compact ovens and grills: 13 x 13 in at 13.1 lb, with the highest listed limit at 1112 °F.
- 13.1 pounds Item Weight
- 1112 °F Maximum Temperature
- 13"L x 13"W x 0.25"Th Dimensions
- Various Material Type
Best for Small ovens and grill use
Skip it if You want 16 in pies; the ThermiChef 16×16 gives more room.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| 1112 °F, the highest listed maximum | 13 x 13 in is the smallest surface |
| 13.1 lb, the lightest | Material listed only as various |
| Peel included | Higher-priced for its size |
Against the next pick: Is 3 in narrower than the VEVOR plate's 16 x 14.5 in but lighter by 1.7 lb.
Also sold as: Stone Pro XL, Circular, Rectangular.
It is the smallest plate here at 13 x 13 in and the lightest at 13.1 lb. Both numbers suit a small oven or a grill. A 16 in pie will not fit.
Its 1112 °F listed maximum is the highest in the set. It includes a peel. The listing names the item type as a pizza stone and material as various, so the exact steel is unclear.
It is higher-priced in this set, a lot for the smallest surface.
Full listing specifications
| Item Weight | 13.1 pounds | Size | Square Steel Pro XL |
|---|---|---|---|
| Number of Packs | 1 | Included Components | peel |
| Item Type Name | Pizza Stone | Maximum Temperature | 1112 °F |
| Item Dimensions L x W x Thickness | 13"L x 13"W x 0.25"Th | Material Type | Various |
| Product Care Instructions | Hand wash with warm water only. | Color | Black |
4. VEVOR 16×14.5 pre-seasoned steel
4 · Best Pre-Seasoned Value
Verdict: For skipping the seasoning step: 16 x 14.5 in, 0.25 in thick, listed pre-seasoned, lower-priced here.
- 14.8 pounds Item Weight
- 500 °F Maximum Temperature
- 16"L x 14.5"W x 0.25"Th Dimensions
- Carbon Steel Material Type
Best for Buyers wanting a ready-to-use steel at a lower price
Skip it if You preheat above 500 °F; Hans Grill lists 1112 °F.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Listed pre-seasoned | 500 °F is the lowest listed maximum |
| 16 x 14.5 in surface | Narrower than the 16 x 16 steels |
| Lower-priced in this set |
Against the next pick: Compare on maximum temperature: 500 °F against Chef Pomodoro's 932 °F.
Also sold as: 15 x 15 x 0.67 Inch / Beige, 20 x 14 x 3/8 Inch / Black, 13.5 x 10 x 1/4 Inch / Black, 16 x 14 x 0.6 Inch / Beige.
The plate is 16 x 14.5 in at 14.8 lb. That is 1.5 in narrower than the 16 x 16 steels, enough to fit most pies.
Watch the listed maximum temperature: 500 °F, the lowest in the set. The listing gives no headroom above 500 °F.
The listing says to wipe with a damp cloth, and says it may turn blue after high heat. It has a thumb hole for hanging.
Full listing specifications
| Item Weight | 14.8 pounds | Size | 16 x 14 x 1/4 Inch |
|---|---|---|---|
| Number of Packs | 1 | Included Components | 1 x Pizza Steel Plate (16" x 14.5" x 1/4") |
| Item Type Name | Carbon Steel Pizza Baking Stone with 20X Higher Conductivity, Heavy Duty Rustproof Pizza Pan for Outdoor Grill, Indoor Oven | Maximum Temperature | 500 °F |
| Item Dimensions L x W x Thickness | 16"L x 14.5"W x 0.25"Th | Material Type | Carbon Steel |
| Product Care Instructions | Wipe with Damp Cloth | Color | Black |
5. Chef Pomodoro 16 in seasoned steel
5 · Best with Lifting Hole
Verdict: For easy handling: a corner finger hole, pre-seasoned, 16.14 x 13.39 in, listed to 932 °F.
- 6.64 kg Item Weight
- 932 °F Maximum Temperature
- 16.14"L x 13.39"W x 0.24"Th Dimensions
- Steel Material Type
Best for Those who value a built-in grip
Skip it if You need clear specs; ThermiChef lists them without conflict.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Corner hole for lifting | Listing gives conflicting size and temperature figures |
| Pre-seasoned | Only 13.39 in wide |
| 16.14 in length |
Against the next pick: Is 2.6 in narrower than the Caldoro 16 in width and lists 932 °F where Caldoro states none.
Also sold as: 14 X 20 – Inch, 14 X 12 – Inch (Pack of 3), 13 X 13 – Inch, 14 X 12 – Inch.
The footprint is 16.14 x 13.39 in, the longest plate in the set. At 14.64 lb it is mid-weight.
The listing is inconsistent. The size field says 16 x 13.25 in while the description mentions a 20 x 14 in plate with a 572 °F maximum, which conflicts with the 932 °F spec. Treat the maximum with caution.
It has a lifting hole and arrives pre-seasoned. The 0.24 in thickness matches the others.
Full listing specifications
| Item Weight | 6.64 kg | Size | 16 X 13.25 - Inch |
|---|---|---|---|
| Number of Packs | 1 | Item Type Name | Baking Pizza Steel Stone |
| Maximum Temperature | 932 °F | Item Dimensions L x W x Thickness | 16.14"L x 13.39"W x 0.24"Th |
| Item Highlight | Steel Pizza Stone Bakes Crispy Pizza & Sourdough Bread, Pre-Seasoned Metal Pizza Stone, Finger Hole for Easy Lifting and Use | Material Type | Steel |
| Product Care Instructions | Hand Wash | Color | Dark Gray |
6. Caldoro 16×16 steel with cutter
6 · Best Gift Set
Verdict: For a gift: 16 x 16 in, 6 mm (0.24 in) plate plus a 14 in oak-handle cutter.
- 16.2 pounds Item Weight
- not stated Maximum Temperature
- 16"L x 16"W x 0.24"Th Dimensions
- Low Carbon Steel Material Type
Best for Gift buyers wanting a boxed set
Skip it if You want a listed heat limit; pick ThermiChef at 1000 °F.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| 16 x 16 in footprint | No maximum temperature stated |
| Includes 14 in cutter | Higher-priced than similar plates |
| Low carbon steel |
Against the next pick: Is 2.6 in wider than Boachee's 13.4 in and 1.9 lb heavier.
Also sold as: 16 Inch Round, 16 x 13.4 Inch.
The plate is 16 x 16 in, matching the ThermiChef, at 16.2 lb and 0.24 in. The extra is a 14 in rocker cutter and care manual.
The listing states no maximum temperature, which matters for hot bakes. It is nitrided with a dark gray finish and needs drying after washing.
It is higher-priced in this set, partly the cutter.
Full listing specifications
| Item Weight | 16.2 pounds | Manufacture Year | 2024 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Size | 16 x 16 Inch | Number of Packs | 1 |
| Included Components | Care Manual, Pizza Cutter, Pizza Steel | Item Dimensions L x W x Thickness | 16"L x 16"W x 0.24"Th |
| Item Highlight | Includes 14-Inch Oak-Handle Rocker Cutter and Care Manual, Nitrided Dark Gray Finish, Holds Heat Between Bakes | Material Type | Low Carbon Steel |
| Product Care Instructions | Dry Thoroughly After Use, Hand Wash Only | Color | Dark Gray |
7. Boachee XL 16×13.4 carbon steel
7 · Best Lower-Priced Rectangle
Verdict: For a lower-priced 16 x 13.4 in plate at 14.3 lb, with a coating that needs no seasoning.
- 14.3 pounds Item Weight
- not stated Maximum Temperature
- 16"L x 13.4"W x 0.25"Th Dimensions
- Carbon Steel Material Type
Best for Budget buyers wanting a rectangular plate
Skip it if You want a rated limit; choose ThermiChef or Hans Grill.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| 14.3 lb, lighter than the 16 x 16 plates | No maximum temperature stated |
| No seasoning required per listing | Coating type is not described |
| Lower-priced in this set |
Against the next pick: Is 0.1 lb lighter than Primica's 14.44 lb build, with the same 13.4 in width.
This is 16 x 13.4 in and 14.3 lb, lighter than the 16 x 16 steels. The listing says it arrives ready to bake with a rust-protective coating.
No maximum temperature is stated, and the coating is not described further. Those gaps matter at high heat.
Size and weight are close to the Primica steel, which also lists no maximum.
Full listing specifications
| Item Weight | 14.3 pounds | Manufacture Year | 2025 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Size | 16" x 13" | Number of Packs | 1 |
| Included Components | Pizza Steel | Item Dimensions L x W x Thickness | 16"L x 13.4"W x 0.25"Th |
| Material Type | Carbon Steel | Product Care Instructions | Hand Wash |
| Color | Matte Black | Shape | Rectangular |
Pizza Steel buying guide
What to check before ordering
- Footprint: compare plate size to your rack; 16 x 16 in needs a deep oven.
- Thickness: 0.25 in suits one pizza at a time; 0.38 in suits batches.
- Weight: from 13.1 lb to 27 lb here; you lift it hot.
- Maximum temperature: listed from 500 °F to 1112 °F; some state none.
- Seasoning: some arrive seasoned, others need an oil bake.
- Extras: a peel or cutter changes the package, not the steel.
Pizza steel questions, answered
How thick does a pizza steel need to be?
0.25 in is enough for one or two pizzas. Go to 0.38 in only for back-to-back baking and if you can handle 27 lb. On a neighbouring topic: best pizza cutter.
How large should it be?
Large enough for your pie but small enough for your rack. 16 x 16 in handles a 15 in pizza; 13 x 13 in suits smaller ovens.
Does it need seasoning?
Depends on the listing. ThermiChef ships unseasoned; VEVOR and Chef Pomodoro list pre-seasoned.
Which max temperature is enough?
A 500 °F preheat is common, so 500 °F leaves no margin. 932 °F or more gives headroom. Several listings do not say.
Also considered
- Primica Pizza Steel XL Beaten on a listed spec Outclassed by Boachee: same 16 x 13.4 in size and no stated maximum temperature, at a slightly higher 14.44 lb.
Where that leaves you
The ThermiChef 1/4 in 16×16 suits a full-size oven and one pizza at a time. Pick the 3/8 in version for batch baking, or the Hans Grill 13×13 for a small oven.
Skip the category if you only bake frozen pies occasionally, or cannot lift 13 lb or more of hot steel.
What changed
- Published guide
- Guide drafted