Restaurant WeekHawaii

8 Best Baking Sheets for Cookies in 2026: Sets & Half Sheets

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. When you click a product link on Restaurant Week Hawaii and buy something on Amazon, Amazon pays us a small commission; the price you pay is the same. Learn more.

You should weigh three things before picking a cookie sheet: how much fits your oven, what the metal does to cookie bottoms, and whether you want a coating.

Size first. A half sheet near 18 by 13 inches bakes a full batch; a 13 by 9 pan suits toaster ovens. Measure your rack before anything else.

Material second. Bare aluminum browns lightly; dark coated carbon steel tends to brown faster; stainless steel sits apart and usually relies on a mat.

Coating third. Nonstick saves parchment but brings a temperature ceiling and hand-wash advice. Uncoated pans tolerate more but need liners for sticky dough.

Count last. Two identical pans let you load one while the other bakes. The best baking sheet for cookies is the one that fits these four answers, not the heaviest or the shiniest.

Our top picks for Baking Sheet For Cookies

The Nordic Ware Naturals 2-pack comes first: bare aluminum, the largest surface here at 17.9 by 12.9 inches, and steel-encapsulated rims against warping. If you want nonstick release in one large pan, the GoodCook BestBake textured sheet wins at 17.75 by 12 inches. Small ovens suit the GoodCook 13×9 three-pack, and the M MCIRCO set adds racks and mats.

Where these picks come from

No product here was handled. The ranking sets the brands’ published specs against each other: outer dimensions, weight, material, coating, stated temperature limits, pan count and warranty. Where a listing leaves a spec out, that gap counts against it.

Specs cannot tell you how a pan feels in a mitt, whether it pops in a hot oven, or how a coating holds up after years of washing.

8 listings were compared on item weight, material type and dimensions. No product was bought or physically handled: every figure is the manufacturer's listing value. Produced by Kitchen & Cookware Desk. Editorial responsibility: restaurantweekhawaii.com.

Baking Sheet For Cookies compared

Each pick carries a short Spec and Value table: outer dimensions, weight, material, pan count and coating. Same rows on every pick, so scroll and compare vertically.

Pick by situation

Our picks for Baking Sheet For Cookies

1. Nordic Ware Naturals half sheet 2-pack

Nordic Ware Naturals Half Sheet - USA Made Aluminum Commercial Quality Sheet Pan for Baking or Roasting, Encapsulated Galvanized Steel Rim Prevents Warping, 2-Pack1 · Best Overall

Verdict: For bakers running two trays per batch: bare aluminum at 17.9 x 12.9 in, the widest pan in this set.

  • 1.7 pounds Item Weight
  • Aluminum Material Type
  • 17.9"L x 12.9"W x 1"H Dimensions

Best for Bakers making two trays of cookies at a time

Skip it if Skip if you want a coated pan; the GoodCook BestBake is the nonstick alternative.

3 pros3 cons
  • Widest pan here at 12.9 in
  • Two pans per pack
  • Lifetime limited warranty
  • No nonstick coating
  • Acidic foods can pit aluminum
  • Higher-priced in this set

Against the next pick: It beats the GoodCook BestBake on width (12.9 in vs 12.0 in) but loses on nonstick release.

Also sold as: 2pk Half + 1/8 Sheet, 2pk Half + Lid.

Aluminum is the deciding spec. The listing credits it with heat conductivity and says the light finish prevents overbrowning, which is the usual failure on dark cookie sheets. The catch: there is no nonstick coating, so expect to use parchment or a mat for sticky doughs.

Interior is 17.1 by 12.1 inches, so the usable floor is a little smaller than the outer size suggests. The brand also warns that acidic foods like tomato and vinegar can darken or pit the pan, which matters little for cookies and more for roasting. Two pans at 1.7 lb total weight keep a rotation going: one in the oven, one cooling.

Short.

The steel-encapsulated rim is the anti-warp measure here, and the listing calls it a lifetime limited warranty product made in the USA.

Full listing specifications
Manufacturer Warranty Description: lifetime limited warrantyNumber of Packs: 2Included Components: half sheet^2Item Type Name: Naturals Baking SheetMaterial Type: AluminumMaterial Type Free: Chemical FreeSize: 2pk Half SheetItem Dimensions L x W x H: 17.9"L x 12.9"W x 1"HItem Weight: 1.7 poundsColor: Natural

2. GoodCook BestBake textured cookie sheet

GoodCook BestBake Nonstick Textured Carbon Steel Cookie Sheet, 11" x 17", Large Baking Sheet, Even Heating, Scratch-Resistant, Non-Toxic, Durable, Ideal for Baking and Sheet Pan Dinners2 · Best Nonstick

Verdict: For bakers who want release without parchment: textured nonstick carbon steel at 17.75 in long.

  • 0.81 kg Item Weight
  • Carbon Steel Material Type
  • 17.75"L x 12"W x 1"H Dimensions

Best for Nonstick fans baking one large tray

Skip it if Skip if you need two pans; the Nordic Ware 2-pack covers that.

3 pros2 cons
  • Textured nonstick surface
  • Angled bakery-style walls
  • PTFE free per listing
  • One pan per pack
  • No temperature limit stated

Against the next pick: It is heavier than the HONGBAKE pair, which does not state weight, but comes as one pan where HONGBAKE ships two at 17.5 in.

Also sold as: Cookie Sheet / 15" x 10" (Champagne), Divided Sheet Pan / 17" x 11" (Divided), Cookie Sheet / 10" x 15" Cookie Sheet.

The diamond-texture surface is pitched at airflow and even heating, plus stiffness. Single pan, so batch rotation means buying a second.

At 1.79 lb it is the heavier of the single large sheets; the plain GoodCook 17×11 is 1.0 lb. Heft usually helps a pan stay flat, though the listing gives no gauge. The side walls are angled at 4 to 5 degrees for straighter edges, useful for bar cookies and sheet cakes, less so for drop cookies. Dark bronze coatings can brown bottoms faster than bare aluminum; the listing does not state a maximum oven temperature.

Full listing specifications
Number of Packs: 1Included Components: 1 Cookie SheetItem Type Name: Cookie SheetMaterial Type: Carbon SteelMaterial Type Free: PTFE FreeSize: 11" x 17" Cookie SheetItem Dimensions L x W x H: 17.75"L x 12"W x 1"HItem Weight: 0.81 kgColor: Bronze

3. HONGBAKE half sheet 2-pack

2 Pack Half Sheet Cookie Sheets for Baking, Nonstick Baking Pans3 · Best Coated Pair

Verdict: For bakers wanting two nonstick half sheets: 17.5 x 11.8 in with a 450°F heat-resistance rating.

  • not stated Item Weight
  • Carbon Steel Material Type
  • 17.5"L x 11.8"W x 1"H Dimensions

Best for Two-tray bakers who want nonstick

Skip it if Skip if you prefer uncoated metal; take the Nordic Ware instead.

3 pros2 cons
  • Two coated pans
  • 450°F rating stated
  • Warranty against peeling
  • Item weight not stated
  • Higher-priced in this set

Against the next pick: It ships two pans where the GoodCook 17×11 ships one, though the GoodCook is longer overall at 19.5 in.

Also sold as: Dark Gray / Jelly Roll / 2, Champagne Gold / Jelly Roll / 1, Dark Gray / Half Sheet / 2, Champagne Gold / Half Sheet / 1.

Two-layer coating, PFOA, BPA and PTFE free per the listing, with a diamond texture like the GoodCook BestBake. The brand claims 57% thicker carbon steel but never says thicker than what, and states no weight. So the claim is hard to use.

Inner size is 17 by 11 inches. Fine for a dozen-plus cookies. Higher-priced in this set, and the 450°F limit sits below what some pizza and roasting recipes call for, though cookies rarely need more.

Full listing specifications
Item Highlight: 57% Thicker Carbon Steel, 17.5" × 12" Half Sheet Size, Long-Lasting Nonstick CoatingMaterial Type: Carbon SteelMaterial Type Free: PTFE FreeSize: Half SheetItem Dimensions L x W x H: 17.5"L x 11.8"W x 1"HColor: Champagne Gold

4. GoodCook Everyday 17×11 sheet

GoodCook Everyday Nonstick Steel Baking Sheet, 17 x 11-Inch, Gray4 · Best Budget Single

Verdict: For a lower-priced single large nonstick sheet; 1.0 lb with a wide grab lip.

  • 16 ounces Item Weight
  • Alloy Steel Material Type
  • 19.5"L x 12"W x 0.9"H Dimensions

Best for Occasional bakers needing one big sheet

Skip it if Skip if your oven is shallow; the 13×9 GoodCook set fits tighter spaces.

3 pros2 cons
  • Lower-priced in this set
  • Metal spatula safe
  • Wider grab lip
  • Lighter than BestBake
  • No temperature limit stated

Against the next pick: It beats the GoodCook three-size set on largest-pan length (19.5 in vs 16.9 in) but gives you one size instead of three.

The listed outer length of 19.5 inches against a 17 by 11 size label suggests the lip adds real width to grip, which the brand mentions. Check your oven rack depth before buying.

Steel, metal-spatula safe, dishwasher safe, limited lifetime warranty. At 1.0 lb it is about half the BestBake’s weight, and the listing does not state gauge or a temperature limit. Lighter pans can flex more; that is the trade for the lower price.

Full listing specifications
Item Highlight: 11 in width, 17 in length, nonstick steel construction, gray finish, everyday baking sheetManufacturer Warranty Description: Limited LifetimeNumber of Packs: 1Included Components: Baking SheetItem Type Name: Baking SheetMaterial Type: Alloy SteelMaterial Type Free: PTFE FreeSize: 17 x 11-InchItem Dimensions L x W x H: 19.5"L x 12"W x 0.9"HItem Weight: 16 ounces

5. GoodCook Everyday three-size set

GoodCook Everyday Nonstick Baking Sheet Set, 3 Pack Includes Small (13×9) Medium (15×10) and Large (17×11) Pans Carbon Steel Construction Cookie Sheets Bakeware Set, Gray5 · Best Size Range

Verdict: For kitchens baking at several scales: small, medium and large sheets in one box.

  • 0.25 kg Item Weight
  • Steel Material Type
  • 16.9"L x 11.8"W x 0.9"H Dimensions

Best for Households baking varied batch sizes

Skip it if Skip if you only bake large batches; the Nordic Ware pair suits that.

3 pros2 cons
  • Three sizes included
  • Limited lifetime warranty
  • Metal spatula safe
  • Hand wash recommended
  • Largest pan smaller than Nordic Ware

Against the next pick: It offers more sizes than the GoodCook 13×9 set, whose three pans are all 13 x 9 in.

Three sizes cover a full batch, a half batch and toaster-oven use. Listed weight of 0.55 lb is an error-prone single figure for a three-pan set, so weight is not useful for comparison here.

Coating is PTFE free and metal-spatula safe. Hand washing is recommended despite the dishwasher-safe label, a small hassle. Its largest pan is 17 by 11, smaller than the Nordic Ware’s interior.

Full listing specifications
Manufacturer Warranty Description: Limited LifetimeNumber of Packs: 3Included Components: 3 cookie sheetsItem Type Name: NonStick Cookie SheetMaterial Type: SteelMaterial Type Free: PTFE FreeSize: 3-Piece SetItem Dimensions L x W x H: 16.9"L x 11.8"W x 0.9"HItem Weight: 0.25 kgColor: Dark Gray

6. GoodCook 13×9 three-pack

GoodCook Everyday Baking Sheet Set Nonstick Carbon Steel Standard-Sized Cookie Sheets for Even Baking, Bakeware Set Includes 3 Pans with Scratch-Resistant Finish, 13x9-Inch, Gray6 · Best for Small Ovens

Verdict: For toaster ovens and compact ranges: three identical sheets at the smallest footprint here.

  • not stated Item Weight
  • Alloy Steel Material Type
  • 13"L x 9"W x 1"H Dimensions

Best for Toaster ovens and small ranges

Skip it if Skip if your oven takes half sheets; the Nordic Ware holds more.

2 pros2 cons
  • Smallest footprint here
  • Three identical pans
  • Weight not stated
  • Fewer cookies per tray

Against the next pick: It is smaller than the M MCIRCO sheets (9 in vs 12 in wide) but avoids their 5.1 lb set weight.

Also sold as: 9" x 6" (2- Piece Set) w/ Rack, 9 x 6.3-Inch (2- Piece Set), 15" x 21" (2-Piece Set), 11" x 17" (2-Piece Set).

13 by 9 inches each. Fewer cookies per tray, so plan more rounds.

Same scratch-resistant, PTFE-free coating as the other Everyday sheets and the same hand-wash advice. The listing does not state item weight. Three matching pans make a rotation possible in a small oven where a half sheet will not fit; other sizes are sold under the same listing.

Full listing specifications
Included Components: Cookie sheetsItem Type Name: NonStick Cookie SheetMaterial Type: Alloy SteelMaterial Type Free: PTFE FreeSize: 13" x 9" (3-Piece Set)Item Dimensions L x W x H: 13"L x 9"W x 1"HColor: Dark Gray

7. M MCIRCO stainless set with racks

M MCIRCO Baking Sheet with Cooling Rack, Baking Mat Set, Set of 67 · Best Complete Kit

Verdict: For bakers starting from scratch: 2 sheets, 2 cooling racks and 2 silicone mats in stainless steel.

  • 5.1 pounds Item Weight
  • Stainless Steel Material Type
  • 16"L x 12"W x 1"H Dimensions

Best for New bakers needing racks and mats

Skip it if Skip if you own racks already; the Nordic Ware pair is the cleaner buy.

2 pros2 cons
  • Racks and mats included
  • Stainless, no coating
  • Conflicting mat temperature figures
  • Heaviest set at 5.1 lb

Against the next pick: It includes racks the NutriChef set lacks but weighs 5.1 lb against NutriChef's 3.1 lb.

Not stated on the listing: material type free. Also sold as: 16x12x1inch (Pack of 2), 12.4×9.6x1inch, 17.3x13x1inch.

Mirror-polished stainless sheets with no coating; the silicone mats handle release, rated to 480°F in the description and 500°F in features, a mismatch to note. Racks fit inside the pans for cooling.

The whole set weighs 5.1 lb, heaviest here. The listing does not state material-free claims like the others do. Higher-priced in this set, but it replaces three purchases.

Full listing specifications
Item Highlight: Stainless Steel Cookie Pan with Cooling Rack, 2 Sheets + 2 Racks + 2 Mats,Baking Pan, Size 16 x 12 x 1 Inch Easy CleanMaterial Type: Stainless SteelSize: 16x12x1inchItem Dimensions L x W x H: 16"L x 12"W x 1"HItem Weight: 5.1 poundsColor: Silver

8. NutriChef three-piece set with handles

NutriChef 3‑Piece Nonstick Cookie Sheets – Carbon Steel Baking Sheet Set with Non Stick Coating & Red Silicone Handles – Oven Pans for Family Baking8 · Best Grip

Verdict: For bakers wanting handles: three coated sheets with silicone grips, oven-safe to 446°F.

  • 3.1 pounds Item Weight
  • Carbon Steel with Non-stick… Material Type
  • not stated Dimensions

Best for Bakers who value grip

Skip it if Skip if you need known sizes; the GoodCook three-size set lists them.

2 pros3 cons
  • Silicone handles
  • Lower-priced in this set
  • No dimensions stated
  • 1-year warranty
  • 446°F limit

Against the next pick: It weighs 3.1 lb, lighter than the M MCIRCO's 5.1 lb, but lacks its racks and mats.

Also sold as: 3-Piece Set (Medium), 6-Piece Set (2 Each Small, Medium & Large), 8-Piece Set, 6-Piece Set.

Silicone handles are the distinct feature, easier with mitts. The 446°F ceiling is the lowest stated limit here, and the listing does not state any sheet dimensions, so oven fit is guesswork.

Lower-priced in this set with a 1-year warranty, shorter than GoodCook’s limited lifetime. Many other set sizes exist.

Full listing specifications
Included Components: Pan SetSet Name: 3-Piece SetSize: 3-Piece Set (Small, Medium & Large)Number of Packs: 1Item Weight: 3.1 poundsItem Type Name: Bakeware SetManufacturer Warranty Description: 1 YEARMaterial Type: Carbon Steel with Non-stick CoatingMaterial Type Free: Bisphenol-A (BPA) Free, Perfluorooctanesulfonic Acid (PFOS) Free, Perfluorooctanoic Acid (PFOA) Free, Polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) Free, Polyvinyl Chloride (PVC) FreeProduct Care Instructions: Hand Wash Recommended, Dishwasher Safe

Must-have criteria

  • Fits your oven. Outer size here runs 13 to 19.5 inches long; measure rack depth first.
  • Light or dark surface. Light aluminum resists overbrowning; dark coatings brown bottoms faster.
  • Rim stiffness. Encapsulated or rolled rims resist warping when cold dough hits a hot pan.
  • Coating limits. Coated pans list ceilings such as 446°F or 450°F; cookies rarely exceed them.
  • Pan count. Two identical pans keep batches moving.
  • Care advice. Several coated sheets say dishwasher safe yet recommend hand washing.
  • Warranty. Lifetime limited versus 1 year is a real gap here.

Questions to settle first

How big a sheet does your cookie batch need?

A half sheet around 17 by 12 inches handles most batches. Use 13 by 9 only if the oven forces it.

How many pans does your baking need?

Two. One bakes while the other cools and reloads.

Is nonstick worth it for cookies?

Only if you skip parchment. With liners, bare aluminum works fine and avoids coating limits.

How much does pan weight matter?

Heavier pans usually flex less, but few listings state gauge, so weight is a rough proxy.

Do you need racks and mats included?

Only if you own none; otherwise they add weight and cost.

Does material affect cookie bottoms?

Yes. Light aluminum browns gently; dark coated steel browns faster, so watch bake times.

So which one?

The Nordic Ware Naturals pair suits anyone baking full batches who is happy using parchment: widest surface, two pans, bare aluminum. If you want nonstick on one large tray, the GoodCook BestBake wins. And if your cookies come from a toaster oven a few at a time, a dedicated sheet may be unnecessary; the tray it shipped with already does the job.

What changed
  • Published guide
  • Guide drafted

Read the full method.